4/28/09

doing the best we can?

a long, long time ago, c asked me a question and posted it on her blog here. for days, i almost commented on her post but not quite. i thought about it on and off often enough, but it largely remained as much of a question as it was to begin with. at one point, i decided that we did try to do the best we could. and indeed, that was the best i could do :).

today, i am glad that i'd let the question brew peacefully within all this while. the answer (well, the best i can do for the present) lies in the core of these enlightening words by byron katie. admittedly, these are things i have thought about for months. but admittedly, i needed more to get to my answer. these were it:
Sin, too, is a concept. Think of the worst thing you ever did. Go into it as deeply as you can, from the perspective of the person you were at the time. With the limited understanding you had then, weren't you doing the best you could? How could you have done it any differently, believing what you believed? If you really enter this exercise, you'll see that nothing else is possible. The possibility that anything else could have happened is just a thought you have now about a then, an imagined past that you are comparing with the real past, which is also imagined. We're all doing the best we can. And if you feel that you've hurt someone, make amends, and thank the experience for showing you how not to live. No one would ever hurt another human being if he or she weren't confused. Confusion is the only suffering on this planet.

5 comments:

Bright Butterfly said...

I suppose I'm still not 100% sure of my answer to this question, but I tend towards this perspective, which Byron Katie expresses so well in saying "within the limited understanding you had then, weren't you doing the best you could? How could you have done it any differently, believing what you believed?"

I don't know that I would have boiled it all down to confusion and confusion as the only form of suffering, but certain aspects of choices certainly are much less clear to us at different points in time, e.g., thus while we might act differently now about some decisions or actions of our past, we didn't have that same level of perspective then, and that made all the difference. Thus, we really did do the best we could given the circumstances, given our state of vision at the time.

It's nice to know that you've still been pondering this. ;) I'll have to come up with some more good questions.

8&20 said...

"believing what you believed?" captured the essence for me. i had earlier argued that we tried to do the best we can, but that our efforts were limited by what we knew of our own capacities. katie's words summarize this well, i think.

when she says confusion, i take it to mean a 'lack of clarity' or a 'lack of knowledge' - an inability to see really. i'm not 100% sure what she meant.

and so - at this point, given her writing and my previous thoughts, and my own experiences - i believe that we *do* always do the best we can :). and as i say - this is the best i can do with this question at this moment :). (and i could take that to infinity :).)

Nikhil said...

i'm not so sure about this - aren't there always moments when we KNOW that in the present moment we aren't doing the best we could? When we laze around/procrastinate, though at the back of our minds we know we should be doing something constructive? When we pass a homeless person on a street and for a fleeting moment think of how we'd like to help them - but then walk on because that would be too much trouble in this moment? When we know we shouldn't eat that one extra piece of cake, as it would be bad for us, but still do, rationalizing "it doesn't matter that much"? I think that understanding precedes action - and that even when we have understanding about something, we often don't act based exactly on that, because it takes effort to do this. There are many moments in which we're all hypocritical, in some small way or another - when our actions don't exactly mirror our beliefs/values - and we know that at the back of our minds in that present moment, but still choose to ignore it.

8&20 said...

nikhil, those are the same reasons i had earlier qualified the statement to "we try to do the best we can". i suppose this may be a matter of technicalities too, but if you factor in all the forces that are pulling us away from our desired actions, then as we act against or succumb to those forces, we're still doing the best we can... given the state of our values, our belief system, everything that has made us what we are at that present moment...

Nikhil said...

ya, except that seems like a tautological way of putting it, and doesn't leave much room/motivation for growth/improvement... :)